December 22, 2014.
Dear Dr. Stefano Marcelli, we noticed that your paper "Gross anatomy and acupuncture: A comparative approach to reappraise the meridian system" is very interesting. We respect you as a pioneer in this field.
Yours sincerely,
Kwang-Sup Soh, PhD, Editor-in-Chief of Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies.

 

The Active Points Test book is published in English ◊
a smart, clinical test for best choice of
effective points
Jessica Kingsley Publishers Ltd., London, Philadelphia, Sydney, Vancouver

 

How many coincidences
need to be found before
we can call them causes?

2008-2017 Stefano Marcelli

home/table of contents - previous - next


:: brown text means unrevised translation or incomplete work ::

NB: the author uses the words "channel", "meridian" and "vessel" as synonyms to define the system of lines, tubes or slices transporting the undemonstrated energy called Qi (pronounce "tchi") to all parts of the body. Anyway he considers "meridian" more suitable for scientific speech and literature, also because it is already employed in other fields of knowledge as in geography and morphogenesis.

 

"Correlation doesn't imply causation": we are fully aware of this, and we know well that "a coincidence does not prove a relationship". A rainstorm can cause a drop in sunlight, but does not turn day into night, since rainstorms happen during the day or night by chance. Nonetheless, the similarity between the shape of the Sanjiao acupuncture meridian around the ear and that of the duodenum-pancreas makes us think there're too many coincidences. So we said to ourselves: "If the duodenum-pancreas meridian has a role in the morphogenesis of the ear and duodenum-pancreas organ, in animals with triangular ears (for example cats) the duodenum-pancreas might also be triangular in shape, and not semicircular like in men".

We performed a web search, whose results are below. In the only valid picture of a cat's pancreas that we found, it has distinct right and left lobes, while a man's pancreas is a whole organ, subdivided into head, body and tail for didactic purposes.


The man's Sanjiao (duodenum) meridian face pathway does not correspond with the shape of cat's ear, because of the feline skull anatomy. A cat's pancreas is quite different from a man's pancreas, and so is its duodenum, which is strictly connected with the pancreas: it is not a semi-circle but a semi-ellipse. Another important fact is that the stomach does not overlap onto the duodenum and pancreas, as indeed happens in men. If the "acupuncture meridians system" exists, and if the Sanjiao meridian exists in the cat's body too, it cannot be as shown here below.


The Sanjiao pathway around the ear and toward the tip of the eyebrow might be as below (two possibilities).

a-b) duodenum; c) pancreas right lobe; d) left lobe; e) spleen; f) stomach.

Pictures of duodenum-pancreas of a dog (on left) and rabbit (on right).

a) pylorus; b) upper duodenum; c) biliary duct; d) lower duodenum; e) pancreatic duct; f) pancreas tail; g) spleen; h) colon; i) ileum; j) left kidney; k) rectum.

   

home/table of contents - previous - next

 


The
Acupunture Daily Qi Flow Apps for iOS - Android


▪ Do you appreciate Dr. Marcelli's anatomical comparative approach to acupuncture research, which on the basis of a rational, methodical study is attempting to give acupuncture the dignity of a science?
If the answer is yes, please download the useful apps developed for iOS and Android. They display on iPhones, iPads and Android phone-tablets devices the daily Qi flow in the Acupuncture Meridian System.
Thank you ▪

iOS Lite version   Android Lite version
iOS Full version   Android Full version
 
The Active Points Test book is published in English ◊
a smart, clinical test for best choice of
effective points